SAR by NMR
One tool used in ligand-based design is structure-activity relationship (SAR) by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). This is a process "in which small organic molecules that bind to proximal subsites of a protein are identified, optimized, and linked together to produce high-affinity ligands."[1] This is the process of analyzing ligands that have some affinity for a protein or other molecule and identifying the structural components of the ligands that are responsible for the binding affinity.
SAR by NMR has high potential for drug development as it can be used to develop drugs that have very high affinity for specific drug targets. Using this tool also allows drug developers to create new drugs with minimal chemical synthesis, which then decreases the cost and time required to discover and develop new drugs.
ABT-737
One example of drug discovery using SAR by NMR includes the development of ABT-737.[2] This compound has been shown to effectively inhibit the over-expression of Bcl-xl. This protein is commonly observed to be over-expressed in many types of cancers and is an inhibitor of apoptosis and may also contribute to chemotherapy resistance. Bcl-xl inhibition by ABT-737 therefore, allows apoptosis to occur and helps to prevent chemo-resistance.
Precursors to ABT-737
Several ligands were discovered to have moderate affinity for Bcl-xl. Using SAR by NMR, each of these precursors were analyzed for structural components and functional groups that are critical for Bcl-xl affinity.
Using the example of ABT-737
Compound 1 actually consists of two ligands: a fluorobiphenyl-based ligand and a naphthalene derivative. The fluorobiphenyl system is significant to the high affinity of ABT-737. It is involved in hydrophobic interactions with Bcl-xl forming a "hydrophobic pocket" and is also contained in the two subsequent compounds. Notice the stability of the biphenyl system. Because of steric hindrance of the ortho-hydrogens, the two benzene rings adopt a dihedral angle of about 28.6° as opposed to an angle of 0° (or perfectly lined up).
Compound 2 and Compound 3 are very similar in structure and contribute many of the same groups needed for high affinity. Coumpound 1 is an acylsulfonamide-based ligand while compound 2 is a nitrobenzenesulfonamide-based ligand. Both of these compounds have the same core structure with the exception of the two methyl substituents (shown with yellow halos) on the terminal benzene ring. These compounds also exhibit hydrophobic bonding with the fluorobiphenyl system but they also include a hydrogen bond between an oxygen from the sulfoxone portion of the ligand to an "N-H" group of a glycine amino acid.
SAR by NMR is also useful for analyzing a drug target to obtain a better understanding of its function and activity as well as identifying similar targets. For example, Bcl-2 and Bcl-w are proteins that were discovered to have structures very closely related to Bcl-xl as well as similar roles as anti-apoptotic proteins.
Bcl-xl: a member of the Bcl-2 family
Bcl-xl is a member of the Bcl-2 family. The protein is comprised of seven alpha helices, no beta sheets, and 221 amino acid residues.
Bcl-xl Inhibition with ABT-737
Inhibiting the over-expression of this protein has been shown to effectively induce tumor regression and increase chemo-sensitivity. This can be done with[3][3] .
- ↑ Shuker S. B., Hajduk P. J., Meadows R. P., Fesik S. W. Discovering High-Affinity Ligands for Proteins: SAR by NMR. Science; Nov 29, 1996; 274, 5292; ProQuest Central pg. 1531.
- ↑ Oltersdorf T., Elmore S. W., Shoemaker A. R. An inhibitor of Bcl-2 family proteins induces regression of solid tumours. Vol 435|2 June 2005|doi:10.1038/nature03579
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 details of the citation